[Build-common-hackers] class vs rules?
dr at jones.dk
Tue Aug 23 16:45:35 UTC 2011
On 11-08-23 at 05:41pm, IOhannes m zmoelnig wrote:
> On 2011-08-23 10:41, Jonas Smedegaard wrote:
> > Classes are composed with extendability in mind, rules are not.
> so if my mindset is non-extendable today i will put foo.mk in rules/
> but what happens if i change my mind, and redesign it to be
Sure, be too messy and you will have problems taking over the World.
Like is the case with CDBS.
Or be too smart and you will have problems taking over the World. Like
I did not invent CDBS. I did not choose to distinguish between classes
and rules. So I cannot tell you why it is divine, only try reflect on
how it makes some kind of sense to me. :-)
I would prefer that we strive towards classes most possible.
> >> esp., why is "gnustep.mk" a 'class' and and "kde.mk" a 'rule'?
> > Both are classes.
> "gnustep.mk" lives in "rules" (despite me claiming it was a "class")
Oh, ok. I must confess that I only looked up kde.mk as I was quite sure
I remembered that being a class - and was right. So you accidentally
flipped them around, and I added to the confusion by only checking on
one of them.
So let me try again:
"kde.mk" is a class (not a rule). I cannot speak for "gnustep.mk" as I
am not familiar with that snippet.
What is the output of "dpkg -S /usr/share/cdbs/1/rules/gnustep.mk"?
> so is the distinction between the two types a theoretical or do you
> find it easy to put a snippet into one of the 2 directories?
For the snippets that I have added to CDBS I found it ease to decide
where it made sense to me to add them, yes. Try grep for my name in the
sources of cdbs itself and challenge me with any of them that I was
involved in - perhaps you disagree with some of my choices (and maybe I
do too now looking back).
> and how about users? is the end-user supposed to guess the
> compositional structure of the snippet they want to use? ;-)
No, not guess, but look: If trying names/paths/variables at random then
it takes quite a bit of monkey coding to hit jackpot, I guess. ;-)
> personally, i usually just do a grep (or similar) over
> /usr/share/cdbs/1/*/* to find if there is anything useful for me...
That's how I use CDBS too. And how I use Perl too, for that matter
(grepping a different path, obviously).
* Jonas Smedegaard - idealist & Internet-arkitekt
* Tlf.: +45 40843136 Website: http://dr.jones.dk/
[x] quote me freely [ ] ask before reusing [ ] keep private
-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Size: 836 bytes
Desc: Digital signature
More information about the Build-common-hackers