jed: loosen build-depend on libslang2-dev >= 2.0.7

Rafael Laboissiere rafael at debian.org
Sat May 19 09:19:07 UTC 2007


* Jörg Sommer <joerg at alea.gnuu.de> [2007-05-19 00:16]:

> G. Milde schrieb am Fri 18. May, 18:28 (+0200):
>
> > If I remember right, the problem is segfaults with earlier versions if
> > files are preparsed (byte-compiled) that use the "string $varible"$
> > syntax. 
> 
> That's a bug in SLang, not in Jed. I really don't see, why we should
> introduce a dependency for this, because Jed still works. [snip]

Well, I tend to agree with Günter that the segfault he mentions is a serious
bug, even if it only happens rarely and the package is mostly usable.

> [snip] libslang2 > 2.0.7 has other bug they might be serious, [snip]

This would be a compelling reason for stick to 2.0.6.  Are you just
supposing that or do you have some evidence that 2.0.7 is buggy?

> but I don't see, why we should force to use the newest version. This makes
> backporting a little bit harder.

Well, we can always remove the version restriction when backporting a
package and document where the pacakge would fail.

> I'm against setting this dependency, because there might be problems in
> the current 2.0.7 that forces people to use an older version what we
> forbid.

It is difficult to take the decision without evidence that 2.0.7 is buggy.
Let us discuss a little bit further about this.  Günter?

-- 
Rafael



More information about the Pkg-jed-devel mailing list