Bug#254243: (no subject)

Olaf van der Spek Olaf at XWIS.Net
Mon Oct 20 10:44:57 UTC 2008


martin f krafft wrote:
> also sprach Olaf van der Spek <Olaf at XWIS.Net> [2008.10.19.1125 +0200]:
>> I think it should be merged with #222324
>> I'm willing to continue work on my patch from 2005 if Luk and Martin agree.
> 
> I don't want to have to rely on a width switch. I'd say that netstat
> should output line-oriented and stop worrying about terminal size.
> First of all, IPv6-connected hosts are unlikely to be so old that
> they can only do width-80 or non-tty terminals, and second, the days
> of tools like route/arp/netstat which present formatted output
> (which is harder to process) are hopefully over in favour of tools
> that print the maximum of information and leave it to other tools to
> do the formatting. I really like /bin/ip for that reason, and
> because its output is the same as its input. Tabular output, like
> netstat, is IMHO not worth the trouble, especially if it means that
> the output cannot be complete.

That's fine for machine readable output, but what about human readable 
output?
And how to handle existing scripts that rely on this specific tabular 
output?







More information about the Pkg-net-tools-maintainers mailing list