[Pkg-netsim-devel] Bug#654261: ns2: FTBFS due to missing otcl

[peter green]

>https://buildd.debian.org/status/package.php?p=ns2&suite=sid <https://buildd.debian.org/status/package.php?p=ns2&suite=sid>
>
>The package fails to configure because of missing otcl:
Well it's not exactly "missing", the package is in the archive
and it was installed for the build, so the question was why
isn't the configure script finding it. 

The cause is multiarchification of the otcl packaging. Lukilly
it's pretty easy to workaround from debian/rules.

Not so lukilly after doing so I get link failures :( and I 
can't figure out the cause.

g++ -Wl,-export-dynamic  -o ns tcp/linux/tcp_naivereno.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_cong.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_highspeed.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_bic.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_htcp.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_scalable.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_cubic.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_westwood.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_vegas.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_hybla.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_illinois.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_yeah.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_veno.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_compound.o tcp/linux/src/tcp_lp.o tcp/linux/ns-linux-c.o tcp/linux/ns-linux-param.o tools/random.o tools/rng.o tools/ranvar.o common/misc.o common/timer-handler.o common/scheduler.o common/object.o common/packet.o common/ip.o routing/route.o common/connector.o common/ttl.o trace/trace.o trace/trace-ip.o classifier/classifier.o classifier/classifier-addr.o classifier/classifier-hash.o classifier/classifier-virtual.o classifier/classifier-mcast.o classifier/classifier-bst.o classifier/classifier-mpath.o mcast/replicator.o classifier/classifier-mac.o classifier/classifier-qs.o classifier/classifier-port.o src_rtg/classifier-sr.o src_rtg/sragent.o src_rtg/hdr_src.o adc/ump.o qs/qsagent.o qs/hdr_qs.o apps/app.o apps/telnet.o tcp/tcplib-telnet.o tools/trafgen.o trace/traffictrace.o tools/pareto.o tools/expoo.o tools/cbr_traffic.o adc/tbf.o adc/resv.o adc/sa.o tcp/saack.o tools/measuremod.o adc/estimator.o adc/adc.o adc/ms-adc.o adc/timewindow-est.o adc/acto-adc.o adc/pointsample-est.o adc/salink.o adc/actp-adc.o adc/hb-adc.o adc/expavg-est.o adc/param-adc.o adc/null-estimator.o adc/adaptive-receiver.o apps/vatrcvr.o adc/consrcvr.o common/agent.o common/message.o apps/udp.o common/session-rtp.o apps/rtp.o tcp/rtcp.o common/ivs.o common/messpass.o common/tp.o common/tpm.o apps/worm.o tcp/tcp.o tcp/tcp-sink.o tcp/tcp-reno.o tcp/tcp-newreno.o tcp/tcp-vegas.o tcp/tcp-rbp.o tcp/tcp-full.o tcp/rq.o baytcp/tcp-full-bay.o baytcp/ftpc.o baytcp/ftps.o tcp/scoreboard.o tcp/scoreboard-rq.o tcp/tcp-sack1.o tcp/tcp-fack.o tcp/scoreboard1.o tcp/tcp-linux.o tcp/linux/ns-linux-util.o tcp/tcp-asym.o tcp/tcp-asym-sink.o tcp/tcp-fs.o tcp/tcp-asym-fs.o tcp/tcp-int.o tcp/chost.o tcp/tcp-session.o tcp/nilist.o sctp/sctp.o apps/sctp_app1.o sctp/sctp-timestamp.o sctp/sctp-hbAfterRto.o sctp/sctp-multipleFastRtx.o sctp/sctp-mfrHbAfterRto.o sctp/sctp-mfrTimestamp.o sctp/sctp-cmt.o sctp/sctpDebug.o dccp/dccp_sb.o dccp/dccp_opt.o dccp/dccp_ackv.o dccp/dccp_packets.o dccp/dccp.o dccp/dccp_tcplike.o dccp/dccp_tfrc.o tools/integrator.o tools/queue-monitor.o tools/flowmon.o tools/loss-monitor.o queue/queue.o queue/drop-tail.o adc/simple-intserv-sched.o queue/red.o queue/semantic-packetqueue.o queue/semantic-red.o tcp/ack-recons.o queue/sfq.o queue/fq.o queue/drr.o queue/srr.o queue/cbq.o queue/jobs.o queue/marker.o queue/demarker.o link/hackloss.o queue/errmodel.o queue/fec.o link/delay.o tcp/snoop.o gaf/gaf.o link/dynalink.o routing/rtProtoDV.o common/net-interface.o mcast/ctrMcast.o mcast/mcast_ctrl.o mcast/srm.o common/sessionhelper.o queue/delaymodel.o mcast/srm-ssm.o mcast/srm-topo.o routing/alloc-address.o routing/address.o lib/int.Vec.o lib/int.RVec.o lib/dmalloc_support.o webcache/http.o webcache/tcp-simple.o webcache/pagepool.o webcache/inval-agent.o webcache/tcpapp.o webcache/http-aux.o webcache/mcache.o webcache/webtraf.o webcache/webserver.o webcache/logweb.o empweb/empweb.o empweb/empftp.o realaudio/realaudio.o mac/lanRouter.o classifier/filter.o common/pkt-counter.o common/Decapsulator.o common/Encapsulator.o common/encap.o mac/channel.o mac/mac.o mac/ll.o mac/mac-802_11.o mac/mac-802_11Ext.o mac/mac-802_3.o mac/mac-tdma.o mac/smac.o mobile/mip.o mobile/mip-reg.o mobile/gridkeeper.o mobile/propagation.o mobile/tworayground.o mobile/nakagami.o mobile/antenna.o mobile/omni-antenna.o mobile/shadowing.o mobile/shadowing-vis.o mobile/dumb-agent.o common/bi-connector.o common/node.o common/mobilenode.o mac/arp.o mobile/god.o mobile/dem.o mobile/topography.o mobile/modulation.o queue/priqueue.o queue/dsr-priqueue.o mac/phy.o mac/wired-phy.o mac/wireless-phy.o mac/wireless-phyExt.o mac/mac-timers.o trace/cmu-trace.o mac/varp.o mac/mac-simple.o satellite/sat-hdlc.o dsdv/dsdv.o dsdv/rtable.o queue/rtqueue.o routing/rttable.o imep/imep.o imep/dest_queue.o imep/imep_api.o imep/imep_rt.o imep/rxmit_queue.o imep/imep_timers.o imep/imep_util.o imep/imep_io.o tora/tora.o tora/tora_api.o tora/tora_dest.o tora/tora_io.o tora/tora_logs.o tora/tora_neighbor.o dsr/dsragent.o dsr/hdr_sr.o dsr/mobicache.o dsr/path.o dsr/requesttable.o dsr/routecache.o dsr/add_sr.o dsr/dsr_proto.o dsr/flowstruct.o dsr/linkcache.o dsr/simplecache.o dsr/sr_forwarder.o aodv/aodv_logs.o aodv/aodv.o aodv/aodv_rtable.o aodv/aodv_rqueue.o aomdv/aomdv_logs.o aomdv/aomdv.o aomdv/aomdv_rtable.o aomdv/aomdv_rqueue.o puma/puma.o mdart/mdart_adp.o mdart/mdart_dht.o mdart/mdart_ndp.o mdart/mdart_neighbor.o mdart/mdart_queue.o mdart/mdart_table.o mdart/mdart.o common/ns-process.o satellite/satgeometry.o satellite/sathandoff.o satellite/satlink.o satellite/satnode.o satellite/satposition.o satellite/satroute.o satellite/sattrace.o rap/raplist.o rap/rap.o rap/media-app.o rap/utilities.o common/fsm.o tcp/tcp-abs.o diffusion/diffusion.o diffusion/diff_rate.o diffusion/diff_prob.o diffusion/diff_sink.o diffusion/flooding.o diffusion/omni_mcast.o diffusion/hash_table.o diffusion/routing_table.o diffusion/iflist.o tcp/tfrc.o tcp/tfrc-sink.o mobile/energy-model.o apps/ping.o tcp/tcp-rfc793edu.o queue/rio.o queue/semantic-rio.o tcp/tcp-sack-rh.o tcp/scoreboard-rh.o plm/loss-monitor-plm.o plm/cbr-traffic-PP.o linkstate/hdr-ls.o mpls/classifier-addr-mpls.o mpls/ldp.o mpls/mpls-module.o routing/rtmodule.o classifier/classifier-hier.o routing/addr-params.o nix/hdr_nv.o nix/classifier-nix.o nix/nixnode.o routealgo/rnode.o routealgo/bfs.o routealgo/rbitmap.o routealgo/rlookup.o routealgo/routealgo.o nix/nixvec.o nix/nixroute.o diffserv/dsred.o diffserv/dsredq.o diffserv/dsEdge.o diffserv/dsCore.o diffserv/dsPolicy.o diffserv/ew.o diffserv/dewp.o queue/red-pd.o queue/pi.o queue/vq.o queue/rem.o queue/gk.o pushback/rate-limit.o pushback/rate-limit-strategy.o pushback/ident-tree.o pushback/agg-spec.o pushback/logging-data-struct.o pushback/rate-estimator.o pushback/pushback-queue.o pushback/pushback.o common/parentnode.o trace/basetrace.o common/simulator.o asim/asim.o common/scheduler-map.o common/splay-scheduler.o linkstate/ls.o linkstate/rtProtoLS.o pgm/classifier-pgm.o pgm/pgm-agent.o pgm/pgm-sender.o pgm/pgm-receiver.o mcast/rcvbuf.o mcast/classifier-lms.o mcast/lms-agent.o mcast/lms-receiver.o mcast/lms-sender.o queue/delayer.o xcp/xcpq.o xcp/xcp.o xcp/xcp-end-sys.o wpan/p802_15_4csmaca.o wpan/p802_15_4fail.o wpan/p802_15_4hlist.o wpan/p802_15_4mac.o wpan/p802_15_4nam.o wpan/p802_15_4phy.o wpan/p802_15_4sscs.o wpan/p802_15_4timer.o wpan/p802_15_4trace.o wpan/p802_15_4transac.o apps/pbc.o diffusion3/lib/nr/nr.o diffusion3/lib/dr.o diffusion3/filters/diffusion/one_phase_pull.o diffusion3/filters/diffusion/two_phase_pull.o diffusion3/lib/diffapp.o diffusion3/ns/diffagent.o diffusion3/ns/diffrtg.o diffusion3/ns/difftimer.o diffusion3/filter_core/filter_core.o diffusion3/filter_core/iolog.o diffusion3/filter_core/iostats.o diffusion3/lib/main/attrs.o diffusion3/lib/main/events.o diffusion3/lib/main/iodev.o diffusion3/lib/main/iohook.o diffusion3/lib/main/timers.o diffusion3/lib/main/message.o diffusion3/lib/main/tools.o diffusion3/apps/gear_examples/gear_common.o diffusion3/apps/gear_examples/gear_receiver.o diffusion3/apps/gear_examples/gear_sender.o diffusion3/apps/rmst_examples/rmst_sink.o diffusion3/apps/rmst_examples/rmst_source.o diffusion3/apps/ping/1pp_ping_sender.o diffusion3/apps/ping/1pp_ping_receiver.o diffusion3/apps/ping/2pp_ping_sender.o diffusion3/apps/ping/2pp_ping_receiver.o diffusion3/apps/ping/ping_common.o diffusion3/apps/ping/push_receiver.o diffusion3/apps/ping/push_sender.o diffusion3/filters/gear/gear_attr.o diffusion3/filters/gear/gear.o diffusion3/filters/gear/gear_tools.o diffusion3/filters/misc/log.o diffusion3/filters/misc/srcrt.o diffusion3/filters/misc/tag.o diffusion3/filters/rmst/rmst.o diffusion3/filters/rmst/rmst_filter.o delaybox/delaybox.o packmime/packmime_HTTP.o packmime/packmime_HTTP_rng.o packmime/packmime_OL.o packmime/packmime_OL_ranvar.o packmime/packmime_ranvar.o tmix/tmix.o tmix/tmixAgent.o tmix/tmix_delaybox.o gen/version.o gen/ns_tcl.o gen/ptypes.o common/win32.o common/tclAppInit.o common/main-monolithic.o -L/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu -ltclcl -L/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu -lotcl -L/usr/lib -ltk8.5 -L/usr/lib -ltcl8.5 -L/usr/lib/x86_64-linux-gnu -lXext -lX11 -lnsl -lpcap -ldl -lm -lm 
tools/queue-monitor.o: In function `QueueMonitor::QueueMonitor()':
queue-monitor.cc:(.text._ZN12QueueMonitorC2Ev[_ZN12QueueMonitorC5Ev]+0x202): undefined reference to `TclObject::bind(char const*, long*)'
queue-monitor.cc:(.text._ZN12QueueMonitorC2Ev[_ZN12QueueMonitorC5Ev]+0x21b): undefined reference to `TclObject::bind(char const*, long*)'
queue-monitor.cc:(.text._ZN12QueueMonitorC2Ev[_ZN12QueueMonitorC5Ev]+0x234): undefined reference to `TclObject::bind(char const*, long*)'
queue-monitor.cc:(.text._ZN12QueueMonitorC2Ev[_ZN12QueueMonitorC5Ev]+0x24d): undefined reference to `TclObject::bind(char const*, long*)'
packmime/packmime_OL.o: In function `PackMimeOpenLoop::PackMimeOpenLoop()':
packmime_OL.cc:(.text+0x85): undefined reference to `TclObject::bind(char const*, long*)'
collect2: ld returned 1 exit status
make[1]: *** [ns] Error 1
make[1]: Leaving directory `/ns2-2.35~rc10+dfsg'
dh_auto_build: make -j1 returned exit code 2
make: *** [build] Error 2
dpkg-buildpackage: error: debian/rules build gave error exit status 2
debian:/ns2-2.35~rc10+dfsg#

I'm not a tcl expert but this looks like a tclcl issue to me. The
versions of tclcl installed are given below

debian:/# dpkg -l *tclcl*
Desired=Unknown/Install/Remove/Purge/Hold
| Status=Not/Inst/Conf-files/Unpacked/halF-conf/Half-inst/trig-aWait/Trig-pend
|/ Err?=(none)/Reinst-required (Status,Err: uppercase=bad)
||/ Name           Version        Description
+++-==============-==============-============================================
un  libtclcl-dev   <none>         (no description available)
ii  libtclcl1      1.20-6         shared library of TclCL
ii  libtclcl1-dev  1.20-6         development files of TclCL
ii  tclcl          1.20-6         tcl2c++ and otcldoc program from tclcl
ii  tclcl-dev      1.20-6         transitional dummy package to libtclcl-dev
debian:/# 

I would cc the maintainers of tclcl but after looking closer it seems they are
the same as the maintainers of ns2 anyway.

P.S. I've attatched the patch for the configure script issue.



-------------- next part --------------
A non-text attachment was scrubbed...
Name: ns2.diff
Type: text/x-diff
Size: 1788 bytes
Desc: not available
URL: <http://lists.alioth.debian.org/pipermail/pkg-netsim-devel/attachments/20120107/7c2fc941/attachment.diff>