[Yaird-devel] Bug#457177: Bug#457177: keep yaird out of Testing

[maximilian attems]

severity 457177 serious
thanks


On Fri, Dec 21, 2007 at 03:44:02PM +0100, Jonas Smedegaard wrote:
> Wether or not each bug is considered release-critical is dealt with at 
> each bugreport.
> 
> Please refer to BTS numbers for each issue, so that detailed discussion 
> about severity can be discussed together with the bugreporters and 
> partiticant, rather than at this new meta-bug.

time has come to evaluate yaird codebase fo the next release
in order to have things working for users in Lenny.
 
 
> >speaking as debian kernel arch maintainer none of aboves topic
> >saw an improvement since etch release,
> >thus i'm asking to keep yaird out of testing.
> 
> I disagree with your judgement that yaird is generally unfit for 
> release.

you escape with general statements,
your response cut off all the technical bugs.
try to respond each point on its own. once they are dealt with
i'm happy to reavaluate the current depreciation of yaird.

the severity is set with my hat as debian kernel arch maintainer.
please stop playing severity ping pong.

> Yaird currently has a single bug (#443821) marked as release-critical,
> and working around that bug (by disabling the INPUT routine) yaird is
> known to work also with recent snapshots of 2.6.24.                             
that bug involves a kernel available from kernel.org since november.

-- 
maks