[pkg-kolab] Kolab + GOsa debugging

Mark Pavlichuk pav5088 at internode.on.net
Mon Oct 27 22:41:16 UTC 2008


Following is Cajus's reply about the rationale behind schema differences :

Am Monday 27 October 2008 07:51:06 schrieb Mark Pavlichuk:
>   Neil Price from the pkg-kolab-devel mailing list has some queries
> about the GOsa kolab2.schema file :
>
> Price,Neil wrote:
> >>   I did a grep for 1.3.6.1.4.1.19414.3.2.5 and it's part of
> >> kolab2.schema.  Fabian Hickert earlier brought my attention
> >> to the fact
> >> that I needed to replace the Kolab provided schema with a
> >> GOsa provided
> >> version.  The Kolab provided version contains :
> >>
> >> objectclass ( 1.3.6.1.4.1.19414.3.2.5
> >>   NAME 'kolabGroupOfNames'
> >>   DESC 'Kolab group of names (DNs) derived from RFC2256'
> >>   SUP groupOfNames STRUCTURAL
> >>   MAY ( mail $
> >>         kolabDeleteflag ) )
> >>
> >>   The GOsa provided version is slightly different :
> >>
> >> objectclass ( 1.3.6.1.4.1.19414.3.2.5
> >>   NAME 'kolabGroupOfNames'
> >>   DESC 'Kolab group of names (DNs) derived from RFC2256'
> >>   SUP top AUXILIARY
> >>   MAY ( mail $
> >>         kolabDeleteflag ) )
> >
> > Thats does not look right. The Kolab one inherits from groupofnames but
> > the Gosa one inherits nothing. Its also AUXILIARY which means (AFAIK)
> > that it cannot be used in a DIT, its only intended for creating other
> > objectclasses.
> >
> > You are also not supposed to mess with these definitions, they are
> > registered with IANA and are supposedly globally unique.
> >
> > Maybe go back to Fabian and ask him to explain the logic behind the
> > change.

The modifications are done by reason. The kolab schema doesn't allow 
bundling
with ordinary group of name objects - which is bad from our point of view.

Be sure that you include our schema files (kolab + rfc) and your slapd 
should
start. We're using these for our productive systems - so it works.

Cajus

-- 
Dipl.-Ing. Cajus Pollmeier <pollmeier at gonicus.de>
*GONICUS GmbH * NL-München * Grasserstraße 10 * D-80399 München
*Tel.: +49 (0) 89 12 02 12 79 - 0 * Fax: +49 (0) 29 32 / 9 16 - 230
*http://www.GONICUS.de

*Sitz der Gesellschaft: Moehnestrasse 11-17 * D-59755 Arnsberg
*Geschaeftsfuehrer: Rainer Luelsdorf, Alfred Schroeder
*Vorsitzender des Beirats: Juergen Michels
*Amtsgericht Arnsberg * HRB 1968
_______________________________________________
GOsa mailing list
GOsa at oss.gonicus.de
https://oss.gonicus.de/mailman/listinfo/gosa




More information about the pkg-kolab-devel mailing list